Showing posts with label Nigeria. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Nigeria. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 2, 2008

Butterfly effect: Kenya, ethnicity and politics in Africa

Regardless of what our masthead says, we’ve come to focus most of our attention on West Africa. Africa, it seems, is the dream for the Attention Deficit Disorder-addled journalist. The continent is far too large, too diverse to attempt to skillfully cover the whole thing. And, let’s be honest: If all of Africa gets pretty short shrift in the English-speaking international press, West Africa proudly languishes on the bottom rung. It’s generally poorer than other regions; French-ier, too. What’s more: few game parks call the region home, and high-quality diving spots have never been its specialty.

So, it may be a bit out of our purview to speak about Kenya’s shameful elections and their violent aftermath. What interested me about the press coverage is that it has been the Americans – mostly the New York Times – that picked up on the ethnic card right away and ran with it. It’s not that the British or French have ignored the issue – ethnic fighting made headlines in Le Monde – but the European stories seem to concentrate primarily on political realities of the two parties and place ethnic tensions secondary. I am not saying either method is better than the other. It may just make light of the difference on how Americans (or U.S. newspapers) view Africa compared to Europeans.

I ♥ term limits
One discussion missing from the coverage – which has been very good, all things considered – is not about local ethnic and political issues, but grander themes affecting the whole continent. As more African countries tilt towards what most people abstractly call “democratic norms,” elections seem much more contested (and fairer) than a decade before. This may because of rising education levels or the growing influence on civil society (another buzz word). But no reform is most likely more important than the presidential term limits. First, term limits provide an easy litmus test on a president’s dedication to constitutionalism: any attempt to change the number of terms and you look like a villain (even if you succeed).

Second, term limits will eventually force presidents out of office, which relegates heads of state to a position at least somewhat subordinate to the needs of their political party. During the age of Africa’s Dinosaurs, it was the need (and power) of the President who trumped all party needs. That’s because the president most likely created the party to fulfill said needs. But even in nominally democratic Burkina Faso where Blaise Compaore has run his party, the CDP, like a personal fiefdom, younger members see the light at the end of the tunnel of his reign and are beginning to yearn to taste a little of the that wine themselves.

What term limits have helped usher in, then, feels like the beginning of a larger seismic shift to more (in general terms) of a Western Hemisphere version of politics. In the New World, by and large, the party machines triumph over personalities. Think of Mexico and the near seventy-year run of the PRI. Think of elections in places like El Salvador which were just smoke-and-mirror affairs where members of the oligarchy merely switched chairs. Think the generation-long Republican stranglehold on the Executive Branch in the United States and the corresponding Democratic iron grip on the Legislative Branch.

As democracies mature and civil institutions strengthen, it becomes imperative for parties who have enjoyed long periods in power to continue their grip on supremacy. Look at Kenya. If the opposition Orange Democratic Movement would come to power, not only would NARC lose the power of the purse, but investigations – studies into scandals and past sins – would spread like a khat bush after a nice long rain.

Those dastardly opposition leaders
There’s a sub-section to this argument. The long-suffering former opposition party leaders who finally reach the throne. Think Cote d’Ivoire and Senegal, where long-term whipping boys were either exiled or forced to show up at the airport come rain or shine and shake hands with every C-list dignitary bent on flying to Africa. Oh, these opposition leaders were given cursory powers, but they mostly were democratic window-dressing.

After humbly spending decades in shame as the ruling party dreamed up new ways to appropriate their reforms, steal their best politicians and beat them come election day, once these former minions got their chance at the throne, they weren’t going to let go. Think the rumors that Abdoulaye Wade grooming his son for power. Think of the (xenophobic?) shenanigans Laurent Gbagbo has stirred up to continue power in Cote d’Ivoire.

Part of the problem is age. Just because opposition leaders fought Africa’s dinosaurs tooth and nail doesn’t mean they were any more committed to democracy than the presidents-for-life. It’s an argument that says a new Africa would benefit from a whole a new generation of politicians, especially in politically ill countries like Zimbabwe. (On a random note, age is one factor why some people support Barack Obama in the United States.)

In a continent full of political realists, the average African doesn’t have to look far to find fault with Kenya’s election. How can voters oust half the ruling party’s cabinet and still bring back the president to power? (One Kenyan opposition leader told the New York Times: “We live in Kenya. We are Kenyans. We know what is happening.”)

Fool us once – shame on you
One of the underlying factors of the opposition’s fury may stem from what they saw on television – in Nigeria. It was during 2007’s other major election in Anglophone Africa where a ruling party acknowledged it helped swing the vote for its candidate in a tainted election. While opposition parties cried foul, a few days of protests – some of them quite violent – eventually fizzled out and the president remains sitting, although with circumscribed powers.

Word travels fast in these parts. Kenyans most likely learned a lot from the precedent of still-born democracy in Nigeria. Kenyans came to understand how far a ruling party can bend the law, install their choice in the Presidential Palace and then make nice and promise never to do it again – all in the name of Democracy. Once that lesson was understood – and most likely a few others – the anger Kenyans possessed towards their own sham election spread like fire. Of course history and local realities play a big role. But this is also a larger African issue. Presidents and heads of state often get together to talk over issues of the day – and most likely trade notes. We can’t underestimate the fact that African citizens fully understand that criminal politics that go down in one country could easily produce a butterfly effect elsewhere.

Thursday, October 11, 2007

Our Nigeria Problem

There’s a voyeuristic side of me that can’t stop reading human rights reports. When I have a little downtime, I’ll scour through old tales of Serbian and Croatian crimes against humanity. Or, I’ll catch up on Charles Taylor’s use of amulets to tell his boy soldiers they’re impervious to bullets. Old narratives from Apartheid-era South Africa, anyone?

The best human rights reporting opens a window to world few people know. That’s a good thing. A talented human rights investigator will give readers plenty of illicit knowledge, dirty little secrets from the underbelly of despotic regime. To me, human rights reporting underscores my twin beliefs that most power is corrupt and there’s some really sick bastards out there.

Yet reading the press reports of Human Rights Watch’s new report on the 2007 elections in Nigeria failed to stir anything but a yawn. Politics in Nigeria are dysfunctional? It’s like someone told me, at 39, that my insurance company isn’t looking out for what is best for me.

Every report has to start somewhere, but “Criminal Politics: Violence, ‘Godfathers’ and Corruption in Nigeria” takes us down the path we’ve all heard before. “Nigeria is mired in a crisis of governance,” the report’s summary begins. “Eight years since the end of military rule, the country’s longest-ever stretch of uninterrupted civilian government, the conduct of many public officials and government institutions is so pervasively marked by violence and corruption as to more resemble criminal activity than democratic governance.”

The authors go on to list Nigeria’s problems. And I quote:

  • Systemic violence openly fomented by politicians and other political elites that undermines the rights of Nigerians to freely choose their leaders and enjoy basic security;
  • The corruption that both fuels and rewards Nigeria’s violent brand of politics at the expense of the general populace; and
  • The impunity enjoyed by those responsible for these abuses that both denies justice to its victims and obstructs reform.

Election violence? Corruption? Impunity? Ordinary Africans will argue those words apply to nearly half the countries on the continent. Maybe more. Would anyone have batted an eye if Human Rights Watch wrote a similar report condemning the faux elections of Zimbabwe or Libya or Egypt? No. That’s the important point. The fact that Nigeria is at least an ornamental democracy is a slap in the face to this West African nation.

Let’s get something straight. In Africa, Nigeria is a codeword for a seriously unwell country. Even the most casual reader of newspapers knows a few head-shaking anecdotes from Africa’s most populous country: the wicked email scams; the violent fight against polio vaccines; the impromptu roadblocks manned by 14-year-olds with Kalashnikovs; the corrupt oil industry that’s bleeding the rest of the country like a back full of leeches.

In Africa a dysfunctional political arena doesn’t necessarily translate into any further suffering for the rank and file. I know this doesn’t jibe with the often frowning analysis from World Bank officials, democracy consultants to USAID and foreign correspondents of major metropolitan dailies. Most Africans have adapted a healthy skepticism regarding the role of politics in their countries. That’s because the state of politics in most countries is not pretty or well organized or even fair. When things seem to hit rock bottom, life often continues apace. Take this from Kwame Anthony Appiah, writing on Ghana’s political crisis of the 1970s in his book In My Father’s House:

“For a Hobbesian, I suppose, the withdrawal of the Ghanaian state, in the face of its incapacity to raise the income to carry out its tasks, should have led to disaster. Yet, despite the extent to which the government was not in control, Ghanaian life was not a brutish war of all against all. Life went on. Not only did people not “get away with murder,” even though the police would usually not have been in a position to do anything about it if they did, but people made deals, bought and sold goods, owned houses, married, raised families.”

I think Human Rights Watch understands this dilemma. (Because they’ve seen so much political dysfunction, they comprehend it very well.) What they may argue is this time, the Nigerian government stepped over the line. The 2007 Nigerian elections did not merely constitute a state retreating from the public sphere. Rather it created an atmosphere where a very sick group of people ran rampant over a nation and killed 300 people in the process. The level of political violence, corruption and impunity reached a never-before seen scale, it went so low that it shocked not only election monitors (who called it the worst they’ve ever seen) but even Nigerians. And there’s something to be said for that.

So, what was the problem? I quote again:

“Many political figures openly recruit and arm criminal gangs to unleash terror upon their opponents and ordinary members of the public.”

  • In Gombe State, for example, politicians openly recruited violent cult gangs to intimidate their opponents and rig the voting on Election Day. Encouraged by the prevailing climate of impunity, these gangs unleashed a wave of violence on local communities that included murder, rape, arson and other crimes.
  • In Rivers State, criminal gangs hired to rig Nigeria’s 2003 elections have since become a law unto themselves, spreading violence and insecurity throughout the restive Niger Delta. Scores of civilians have either been killed or injured during clashes involving those gangs since the 2007 elections alone.
  • No one has been held to account for sponsoring these gangs.

Here’s the part that gained so much press in the U.S. (Quoting again from the report)

  • In some states, powerful and violent political “godfathers” have gained control over politicians who are dependent on those sponsors to provide protection and fight their street battles. In return, the godfathers have captured government institutions to serve their own interests.
  • In Oyo State, People’s Democratic Party (PDP) godfather Lamidi Adedibu recruited gangs that sowed terror on the streets of Ibadan and other cities while fighting to preserve Adedibu’s power and influence in the state.
  • In Anambra State, a godfather whose political power may now be on the wane has nonetheless so far gone unpunished for his role in fomenting violence and corruption.

What may have begun as a ho-hum report finishes as a thoroughly researched, well reasoned and admittedly angry look into the state of Nigerian politics. The report contains enough grisly details for sickos like me who think he’s heard it all before. There’s also enough ammunition for those who know – and love – Africa to find a way out of this mess. But there’s also a chilling reminder: Our government looks to Nigeria for oil because politics appear to be a lot less messy near the Gulf of Guinea than the Persian Gulf. How are we not going to make the same mistake twice?